ScanMyEstimate
• Real-World Audit Case Studies

Audited Auto Repair Estimates

Compare actual mechanic repair quotes against published industry flat-rate guides, OEM factory warranty schedules, and regional door rates. See how estimating software markups and labor overlap inflation are detected and negotiated down.

2019 Honda Civic EX 1.5L Turbo
San Jose, CA (95123)
0W-20 Synthetic Oil Change (3.7 qt) + Brake Fluid Hydraulic Flush (DOT 4)
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $388.50
Fair Standard $292.00
Potential Savings $96.50
Vehicle Segment Japanese Compact

Detected +0.6 hr overage on brake fluid flush labor ($216.00 quoted vs $108.00 standard flat rate).

2018 Honda CR-V EX-L 1.5L Turbo
Sunnyvale, CA (94086)
Front Ceramic Brake Pads + Coated Brake Rotors Pair + Caliper Service
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $626.00
Fair Standard $418.00
Potential Savings $208.00
Vehicle Segment Compact SUV

Detected inflated 2.0 hr labor time vs 1.4 hr standard flat-rate guide, plus 65% markup on replacement rotors.

2016 Mercedes-Benz E350 3.5L V6
Sunnyvale, CA (94086)
Front Ceramic Brake Pads, Coated Rotors & Wear Sensors Replacement
Fair Standard
Quoted Total $769.97
Fair Standard $688.00
Potential Savings $81.97
Vehicle Segment European Luxury

Estimating software +20% default labor markup detected, fully offset by shop courtesy discount credit.

2021 BMW X5 xDrive40i 3.0L Turbo
Newport Beach, CA (92660)
M-Sport 4-Piston Brake Pads, 374mm Semi-Floating Rotors & CBS Reset
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $1180.00
Fair Standard $840.00
Potential Savings $340.00
Vehicle Segment Luxury SUV

Dealership labor rate of $245/hr and 2.2 hrs billed vs 1.5 hrs standard factory flat rate.

2019 Toyota RAV4 XLE 2.5L Dynamic Force
Dallas, TX (75204)
OEM Iridium Spark Plugs (4x) + Micro-V Serpentine Drive Belt R&R
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $555.00
Fair Standard $390.00
Potential Savings $165.00
Vehicle Segment Compact SUV

Shop quoted 1.5 hrs for spark plugs (standard book time is 0.8 hr) and missed drive belt access overlap.

2018 Ford F-150 3.5L Twin-Turbo EcoBoost
Phoenix, AZ (85001)
Engine Water Pump Assembly R&R + Thermostat + Vacuum Coolant Bleed
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $1050.00
Fair Standard $785.00
Potential Savings $265.00
Vehicle Segment Full-Size Truck

Uncredited cooling system teardown overlap on thermostat replacement during water pump disassembly.

2017 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 5.3L V8
Denver, CO (80202)
High-Torque Starter Motor R&R + 12V Group 48 AGM Battery & BMS Relearn
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $890.00
Fair Standard $665.00
Potential Savings $225.00
Vehicle Segment Full-Size Truck

Starter motor labor billed at 2.2 hrs vs standard flat rate of 1.5 hrs on EcoTec3 chassis.

2020 Toyota Camry 2.5L 4-Cylinder
Atlanta, GA (30303)
High-Output 130A Alternator R&R + Drive Belt Tensioner Inspection
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $740.00
Fair Standard $560.00
Potential Savings $180.00
Vehicle Segment Midsize Sedan

Excessive labor time allocation and uncredited belt removal overlap on alternator service.

2018 Subaru Outback 2.5i Boxer AWD
Seattle, WA (98101)
Front Complete Strut Assemblies (Pair) + 4-Wheel Computer Alignment
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $1150.00
Fair Standard $880.00
Potential Savings $270.00
Vehicle Segment AWD Crossover

Quick-strut assemblies billed at bare-strut rebuild labor hours (2.8 hrs vs 1.8 hrs assembly time).

2019 Audi A4 2.0 TFSI Quattro
Chicago, IL (60601)
Timing Chain Kit, Hydraulic Tensioner & Lower Timing Cover Gasket
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $2450.00
Fair Standard $1890.00
Potential Savings $560.00
Vehicle Segment European Luxury

Factory warranty book time is 5.2 hrs; independent shop billed 6.8 hrs plus 40% markup on genuine Audi chain guides.